Home About Me

The Physicist Who Went Undercover in the Science Wars

In 1996, Alan Sokal, a physics professor at New York University, published an essay with a title that sounds like a parody of the worst excesses of cultural theory: “Transgressing the Boundaries: Towards a Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity.” It appeared in Social Text, in a special issue devoted to the “Science Wars.” Almost at the same time, Sokal sent a second piece to Lingua Franca called “A Physicist Experiments With Cultural Studies.” That second essay was the confession. Sokal admitted that he had wanted to find out whether he could “publish an article liberally salted with nonsense if (a) it sounded good and (b) it flattered the editors’ ideological preconceptions?” The answer, plainly, was yes.

On the surface, the story is simple: a scientist with a taste for mischief wrote a plausible-sounding but empty paper, and a humanities journal, overawed by the jargon, published it. But to understand why the episode landed so hard, it helps to go back a couple of decades.

By the mid-to-late twentieth century, philosophy of science had reached an uncomfortable phase. The old picture of science as observation followed by induction had already been attacked by the conjecture-and-refutation model. Then, as historians examined actual scientific practice in detail, the rational shine around science began to wear off. Scientific change, it turned out, did not proceed according to either of the tidy schemata. It was often illogical, contingent, and shaped by human factors. Theories survived not only because they were internally coherent, but sometimes because their older defenders died, or because a younger generation found a new vocabulary more persuasive. These were real problems, and scientists who preferred research to philosophy had little to say about them. Meanwhile, in the humanities, postmodernism was in full flood, and its suspicion of all claims to truth and objectivity made the critique of science especially attractive. The natural scientists had not yet done much public soul-searching on their own, but that did not stop critics from doing it for them.

Most scientists did not take the critique too seriously. History was history, and they had experiments to run. But being constantly scolded by people who seemed to know little about the practice of science was irritating. Sokal’s hoax was, among other things, a way of saying: if you are going to talk about physics, at least learn what you are talking about. He was also a leftist, and he did not enjoy watching fellow leftists follow figures who knew almost nothing about scientific theory while speaking in grand, revolutionary tones.

The other side had its own account. Social Text’s editors later said they had sensed that something was off in the article and had asked Sokal for revisions, but he ignored them. They also suggested that publishing a physicist was itself encouraging: they did not find his argument especially novel, but he was one of the few people from the natural sciences who had submitted anything. After the hoax was exposed, they tended to see Sokal as a bad comrade who had stabbed the left in the back and disrupted the broader Science Wars at a delicate moment. That reaction was revealing. It suggested that at least some of the editors still did not grasp what Sokal was doing. They treated the affair as an act of betrayal rather than as an invitation to reflect on the standards of evidence and argument in their own field.

There is a suspicion worth entertaining here: the supposed chasm between the natural sciences and the humanities is often kept alive by one side imagining an enemy. One group thinks it is simply going about its business; the other reads that business as provocation or innuendo. Then a fight breaks out over a misunderstanding that neither side has fully examined. Soon there are spectators, people selling peanuts and popcorn, self-appointed mediators, bystanders picking sides without knowing the details, and others pouring fuel on the fire. The scene is familiar.

Academic life is not immune to this, and the wider public is no better. It may be worth remembering the old injunction to “stay foolish”—not as a pose, but as a genuine recognition of one’s own limits. That, perhaps, was the lesson Sokal’s stunt was designed to deliver. The full article, it must be said, is notoriously difficult to finish. I have tried more than once and failed. It remains impressive in the way that only a truly opaque hoax can be—a masterful piece of bait.